Keep Your Readers Hooked by Dropping the Right Clues

Janice Hardy with 3 thinks to remember when considering foreshadowing
By Janice Hardy, @Janice_Hardy

Foreshadowing might seem like a technique that applies mostly to mystery writers, but all stories rely on the classic “what might happen next?” question. Even in a romance, there are secrets to be revealed and histories to uncover, and where that information is learned affects a novel’s pacing. It’s the need to know that draws readers in and keeps them reading. Drop the right clues at the right time and readers will be glued to the pages.

Well-crafted foreshadowing puts those readers in the right mindset long before they reach a scene, and makes them anticipate that scene. Secrets unfold in surprising, yet inevitable ways, and readers feel as though the clues were there all along if only they’d seen them—because they were.

Too much too soon and there’s nothing left to learn (and no reason to read). Too little for too long risks frustrating readers, because they never learn anything new.

No matter what type of mystery your novel uses, look at where your clues and foreshadows appear. If you’re unsure how these elements should unfold, consider:

When and where you want readers to start suspecting the truth:
Establishing patterns is a useful foreshadowing technique. Tension builds when readers are expecting something and waiting eagerly for it to happen.

Don’t forget the value of the Rule of Three here:

  • The first time someone sees something, they merely see it.
  • The second time, they notice it, because it stands out now.
  • The third time, they’re looking for it because you’ve established a pattern to anticipate.

For example, if you want to foreshadow a misunderstanding that has dire consequences, you might have the protagonist misunderstand something minor in the first few chapters. Later on, she might get something else wrong due to distraction. Now you’ve established a pattern that the protagonist doesn’t always listen and misunderstands what she hears. Readers will be looking closely at all her assumptions from then on to see if she’s missing something important. When the big moment occurs, tensions will be higher because readers won’t know if she’s right this time, or if she’s missed something yet again.

Or you might drop hints about an item to be used later. When the protagonist arrives at a quaint bed and breakfast for a yoga retreat, she is surprised to see a shotgun hanging above the fireplace and makes a comment. The next guest to arrive notices the gun and makes a joke about it. When the third guest arrives, readers expect the gun will come up again. And that will make them wonder when, where, and how that gun will be used in the story.

Or, you can be more subtle about it and tap into a reader’s subconscious. Say you want to foreshadow that blue means bad. You might have the protagonist get into an accident with a blue car early on. Then she has a run in with an office rival who knocks blue ink all over her. You might toss in her snagging her new blue skirt and tearing it right before she goes into an important meeting. After that three-step setup, readers will be looking for blue things and anticipating the problems they might cause.

These types of hints can happen over the course of one scene or the whole novel. It’s the creak in the night, followed by the thump, followed by the guy in the ski mask jumping out at you.

When and where you want the protagonist to start figuring it out: Readers often spot details long before characters do, but if the clues are too obvious, then the characters look dumb if they haven’t figured them out as well. Check to make sure you have a good balance between reader hints and character hints. If your protagonist needs to know something by page 45, make sure you’ve left enough clues so the realization feels plausible.

One mystery-writer’s trick is to hide important clues in the middle of the paragraph. Readers don’t pay as much attention to what’s in the middle of a paragraph, but they do focus on the beginning and end of that same paragraph. So they see it, but it often doesn’t jump out at them.

Beware of foreshadowing too much. If you’re dropping clues every chapter, readers will figure out the secret long before they get to the reveal.

Adding suggestive and evocative details: There have been a slew of movies, TV shows, and Vegas acts that have the protagonist—usually some type of con man—setting up a mark (the victim) to think or respond a certain way. They use subliminal clues to suggest what they want the mark to think or say. Drop enough clues with the numbers three and six in front of someone, then ask them to pick a number between ten and forty, and you’ll get a lot of thirty-sixes.

To put ideas in readers’ heads, plant a few suggestive clues. Don’t explain or draw attention to any of them, but if you want readers to think “blue means bad,” then put in something blue whenever something bad happens. Associate blue with bad in their minds, so by the time your protagonist reaches why blue is bad, readers will already feel apprehensive.

Foreshadowing is a handy way to raise tensions, and a well-planned story puzzle leaves lots of clues that readers can look back on and see that the answers were there the whole time.

Do you plan your foreshadowing or does it happen naturally?

Win a 10-Page Critique From Janice Hardy

Three Books. Three Months. Three Chances to Win.

To celebrate the release of my newest writing books, I’m going on a three-month blog tour–and each month, one lucky winner will receive a 10-page critique from me.

It’s easy to enter. Simply visit leave a comment and enter the drawing via Rafflecopter. At the end of each month, I’ll randomly choose a winner.

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Looking for tips on revising your novel? Check out my new book Revising Your Novel:

ryn-2x3

First Draft to Finished Draft, a series of self-guided workshops that help you revise your manuscript into a finished novel. Still working on your idea? Then try my just-released Planning Your Novel Workbook

janice-hardy-rgb-72-3x4Janice Hardy is the award-winning author of The Healing Wars trilogy and the Foundations of Fiction series, including Planning Your Novel: Ideas and Structure, a self-guided workshop for planning or revising a novel, the companion Planning Your Novel Workbook, Revising Your Novel: First Draft to Finished Draft and the upcoming Understanding Show, Don’t Tell (And Really Getting It). She’s also the founder of the writing site, Fiction University. For more advice and helpful writing tips, visit her at www.fiction-university.com or @Janice_Hardy.

Website | Facebook | Twitter | Goodreads | Amazon | Barnes & Noble | iTunes | Indie Bound

*Excerpted from Revising Your Novel: First Draft to Finished Draft

3 things to consider when using foreshadowing (from @Janice_Hardy): Click To Tweet

Elizabeth Spann Craig

View posts by Elizabeth Spann Craig
Elizabeth writes the Memphis Barbeque series (as Riley Adams) and the Southern Quilting mysteries for Penguin and writes the Myrtle Clover series for Midnight Ink and independently. She also has a blog, which was named by Writer’s Digest as one of the 101 Best Websites for Writers. There she posts on the writing craft, finding inspiration in everyday life, and fitting writing into a busy schedule.

50 Comments

  1. L. Diane WolfeSeptember 19, 2016

    There are so many ways you can increase tension in any story. I really like her Rule of Three. It’s a pattern a writer can easily follow.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      And it works in so many different ways, too. It’s a great way to establish patterns.

  2. Margot KinbergSeptember 19, 2016

    This is very useful advice, for which thanks, both. The Rule of Three is an interesting way to look at how to keep readers involved and interested, too.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      Thanks! The classics never go out of style :)

  3. Alex J. CavanaughSeptember 19, 2016

    That helps because I am not great at foreshadowing. Or symbolism.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      I hope it helps! Sometimes it’s easier to go back on the second draft and add the foreshadowing, or see what symbols or themes might have developed naturally. You don’t always have to know those things before you start writing.

  4. Morgyn Star (@MorgynStar)September 19, 2016

    And this works for all fiction, not just mystery!

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      Absolutely!

  5. Mary NelliganSeptember 19, 2016

    I’m going back into my manuscript now to look for places to add Rule of Three clues. Great ideas!

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      Glad it was helpful!

  6. Pam HarstadSeptember 19, 2016

    Interesting. This also fits with watching for too much backstory too early.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      Definitely. Making readers want to know the backstory is great way to slip it into the book. Drop a few teasers, pique curiosity, and when readers are dying to know the answers you can spend some time on the backstory and they won’t mind the pause in the story.

  7. M.A. FieldsSeptember 19, 2016

    I have struggled with not making the clues so obvious, I like the idea of burying them in the middle of a paragraph. More great advice. Thanks.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      Most welcome. Readers pick up on more things than we think, so don’t be afraid to be subtle in an early draft. Let your beta readers help you determine what’s too subtle and what clues you might need to make more obvious.

  8. Becki J. KiddSeptember 19, 2016

    Very interesting about putting the comment in the middle of the chapter. This is rarely where I put it. Must incorporate this technique.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      It’s a great way to sneak information in :)

  9. Christina MercerSeptember 19, 2016

    Another great article! Love threading little hints this way throughout a story :)

    1. Janice HardySeptember 19, 2016

      Thanks!

  10. Gwen GardnerSeptember 19, 2016

    Thanks, Elizabeth. I’m a third of the way through a cozy mystery right now and this will be helpful.

    1. Elizabeth Spann CraigSeptember 19, 2016

      Gwen–Good luck with your cozy! These are Janice’s tips–very useful for mystery writers and for writers of other genres. Her blog is a fantastic resource for writers. Thanks, Janice!

    2. Gwen GardnerSeptember 19, 2016

      Oh sorry, I meant “thank you Janice and Elizabeth”! I really do love these reminders and ideas for foreshadowing and planting clues!

    3. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      Oh good! Best of luck with it.

  11. IngeSeptember 19, 2016

    I work backwards when checking on foreshadowing :)
    Whether my stories were the short fanfiction ones I wrote before, or the long ‘real’ one I’m working on now, I usually only know what will really happen when I reach the end, and only then can start checking if I did the foreshadowing right – checking all chapters, making sure nothing comes ‘out of the blue’, but nothing is too obvious either. it is a difficult balance indeed, thanks for the tips on nice alternative ways to put foreshadowing in (I like the associative/suggestive idea – it is a lot more subtle than the usual stuff)

    1. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      Working backward is so helpful for so many things (like editing and proofreading, plotting). I can see it working well for foreshadowing, too. Glad I could help make the process easier for you.

  12. C. Hope ClarkSeptember 19, 2016

    What a perfectly brilliant simply idea. Thanks!

    1. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      Most welcome! Glad you enjoyed it.

  13. LauraSeptember 19, 2016

    I love foreshadowing (the good kind)! It really is important no matter what you write.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      It is. I was reading an urban fantasy my husband recommended, and at one point I saw something in the story, turned to him and said, “If she doesn’t do X by the end of this series I’ll be so mad.” And sure enough, a few books later she did X. I saw it coming and it was so perfect and so awesome I looked forward to that moment for two more books. :)

  14. JC MartellSeptember 19, 2016

    Particularly like the “blue is bad” tips. Conditioning our readers like Pavlov’s dog – without the saliva.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      Much less messy that way :)

  15. Julie HolmesSeptember 19, 2016

    Great tips. Sometimes knowing how much to foreshadow or hint at is tricky. You’veoi pointed out some good things to keep in mind. Thanks!

    1. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      Most welcome! A lot of times it’s hard to tell until the draft is done, so it helps to not worry about it *too* much until draft two.

  16. Debbie JohanssonSeptember 19, 2016

    This is great advice Janice. I’ll be sure to be referring to these techniques from now on. Thanks Janice and Elizabeth for this informative post.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      Thanks! Glad you liked it.

  17. StephanieSeptember 19, 2016

    I’ve been wondering with my current manuscript (an urban fantasy/crime novel) if I’m foreshadowing enough. Now I have some great techniques to go back and check! :) Thank you!

    1. Janice HardySeptember 20, 2016

      Oh good, glad it found you at just the right time :)

  18. Amy M. ReadeSeptember 20, 2016

    Great tips! I especially liked the examples of using color to foreshadow something bad. I hadn’t consciously thought of using that in my books–I might have to give that a try!

    1. Janice HardySeptember 21, 2016

      Thanks! Color is evocative, so you can use it like mood lighting :)

  19. NicolaSeptember 21, 2016

    An extremely useful post – especially as I’m currently revising my novel. Thank you for sharing.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 21, 2016

      Thanks, glad it helped.

  20. ConnorSeptember 21, 2016

    Foreshadowing is very important for thrillers, too. There’s a fine line between informing the reader enough and informing the character too much, though, and I struggle with this.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 21, 2016

      Absolutely. I think the more suspense the novel has overall (no matter what genre it is), the more impact foreshadowing has.

  21. chemistkenSeptember 21, 2016

    I plan my foreshadowing. The hard part for me is slipping it into the story naturally without drawing attention to it. Thanks for the suggestions, Janice.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 22, 2016

      Most welcome, hope they helped :)

  22. ChristySeptember 22, 2016

    I really appreciate the work it must have taken to organize this blog tour. The articles are invaluable, and the introduction to new blog sites is fun.

    1. Janice HardySeptember 22, 2016

      Aw, thanks so much! I’m extremely lucky that almost every single person I asked said yes. Such an amazing group of bloggers and I’m grateful they let me hang out with them.

      It also helped to mix in a lot of excerpts from the new books -grin-. But I figured that was a win/win for everyone, hehe.

  23. Meg WolfeSeptember 22, 2016

    Thanks, Janice and Elizabeth–this post is going into my precious Checklist Folder of concise and actionable craft techniques. I’m getting book #4 ready for the beta readers and the timing of this advice couldn’t be better!

    1. Janice HardySeptember 22, 2016

      Awesome! I love when the right post hits the right writer t the right time. Good luck on your upcoming revision.

  24. […] 3. Hooking your reader is so important. Janice Hardy has a guest post on Elizabeth Spann Craig’s site with some tips on how to Keep Your Readers Hooked by Dropping the Right Clues. […]

  25. Monday Must-Reads [09.26.16]September 26, 2016

    […] Keep Your Readers Hooked by Dropping the Right Clues – Elizabeth Spann Craig […]

Comments are closed.

Scroll to top