Cozy Mystery Writing: Suspect Interviews

by Elizabeth S. Craig, @elizabethscraig

Suspect interviews aren’t quite as simple as they may seem.   Something that may seem very straightforward for a police officer can be very different for a gifted amateur.

Here are some possible pitfalls and some workarounds for interviewing your cozy mystery suspects:

Why should anyone give an amateur sleuth information at all?  Unlike a police interview where a suspect might feel compelled to answer questions, an interview with an amateur sleuth is more like a conversation gone wrong.  Suddenly, the person the suspect is talking with becomes very nosy about uncomfortable events or something rather personal.

There are different ways to go about this.  You could have your sleuth be someone especially likeable and easy to talk to…someone that people automatically open up to. You could have your sleuth be a professional snoop: maybe a journalist or a private investigator. Or you could go the route where your sleuth is discounted and underestimated by the suspect:  Agatha Christie’s Miss Marple is an excellent example of this.Continue reading

Writing the Cozy Mystery: The Suspects

By Elizabeth S. Craig, @elizabethscraigfile000557708328

This is the second in my cozy mystery writing series.  Last week I focused on writing better sleuths. Today, I thought I’d take a look at another vital element for a solid mystery: good suspects.

How many suspects?  Fewer suspects can be easier for readers to keep up with, but can also mean that the murderer’s identity isn’t as much of a surprise.  If you have more suspects, you can more easily maintain the element of surprise at the end, but you have to be careful not to confuse the reader.  I usually prefer 5 suspects, killing one of them during the course of the book.  If you choose to have a lot of suspects, you can reduce confusion by making sure their names are very distinct or by giving them a casual reintroduction when they appear “onstage” again in the story.Continue reading

Scroll to top