I’m a New Author. What is the Best Way to Get Published?—Guest Post by Marvin Wilson (The Old Silly)

Marvin Wilson

Thanks so much to Marvin Wilson for guest blogging for me today! Marvin is “An old Hippie rock and roller, a non-religious, dogma free, Maverick spiritualist Christian. I am an author, with the audacity to write novels. I also am an editor. I’m on the editors staff at All Things That Matter Press and also do freelance. For a rate quote, contact me at marvwilson2020@gmail.com.”

Having gone through the daunting and laborious task of getting that first book published, I thought I’d take some time and write down some things I’ve learned along the way. Maybe some talented new writer can read this and cut down on the amount of frustration, confusion, and anxiety that I went through trying to break through the barrier from “amateur writer” to “published author.” As the published author of just three books so far, with three more scheduled to be published in 2010, I am certainly no senior writing sage – don’t profess to be. However, I am a quick learner, and I think that if you are new to this industry, or even started on your way, you will find my observations and recommendations more than sophomoric. Let’s get started.

First, you have to know what you want, and at the same time you must be realistic in your expectations. Unless you are already famous in some other area, in the literary world you are an unknown. If you have never had a magazine or newspaper article published, never hosted a successful blog, never had so much as a poem in print anywhere, no literary resume of any weight, you have to realize that nobody knows you, and nobody cares that you’ve written a book, even though you may believe it’s the next Great American Novel. Your friends and family have read your manuscript. They may have filled your head with affirmations of how wonderful your precious book is, encouraging you to get it published, assuring you that you are at least equal to Stephen King and will most surely be fantastically successful.

Probably not. Not with your first go-around. Maybe not even with your second or third or fourth book. The King himself went through decades of living as a starving artist before his breakthrough novel, “Carrie,” vaulted him into ‘overnight’ success. (Read On Writing by Stephen King. This is mandatory reading for all aspiring authors). Trying to get a major publisher or literary agent to pick you up, as a novice, is about as easy as herding cats, and as much fun as a root canal. If you go about it the wrong way, you may well become despondent, frustrated, and give up. This article is intended to help you find your way with some clear, proven methods of getting your writing career up and running.

So, let’s get started. Here are your down-to-earth choices, Mr. or Mrs. Novice Author. There are four realistic choices available to you.

They are-
1. Self-publish
2. Go with a vanity press
3. Go with a POD
4. Get a contract with a small traditional publishing house

Choice number one: you can self-publish. This is a monumental undertaking. You buy your own ISBN number, you copyright the work yourself, you produce the cover art (or pay an artist for it), you hire a printing press to produce the copies (Amazon.com now has a self-pub option with BookSurge that makes it a little easier, I’ve been told), and then you seek a distributor to distribute your books (which you probably will not be able to get) or you market and sell your books yourself. True self-publishing makes sense only if your work is too controversial for any publisher to print, or if your book relates only to a small geographic area, or perhaps if you just want to produce a textbook for a class you are teaching in some obscure subject that you are an expert at – those types of scenarios. Otherwise, it’s too much work (for this author, at least) to take on.

While the next two options are often (mistakenly) called “self-publishing,” they are actually not. These are publishing houses that do it (all that work we discussed above) for a fee. They are the vanity presses and the POD (print on demand) publishers. Some of the better known vanity presses are iUniverse, XLibris and AuthorHouse. But there are hundreds of them, just do a Google search. They are the easiest way to publish. With many of them, you just pay a fee and they’ll publish your work, even if what you’ve written is the most pathetic drivel ever penned. So if you are with me so far, we are now left with two other choices. Get with a good, reputable POD publisher, or go for a small traditional publisher’s contract. Let’s talk the POD route first.

A good POD publisher will have standards. The more respectable the outfit, the higher the standards. They don’t publish just any rubbish. You will in most cases need to submit a query letter to get their attention. You also need to investigate the company enough to know if they are accepting submissions and/or queries at this time. Remember, they are small; they can only publish so many books in any given year. Nowadays they all have websites, so go there and read up on them. Find out what genres they accept and which they do not. Most do not want a full manuscript submission before reading your query. If they like your query, they will usually ask for a sample first three chapters.

Know this: submission guidelines vary – so do your homework. Your book could miss a chance at being published just because you didn’t take the time to read up on how a particular publishing house wants you to submit your query/sample/manuscript. That nettles veterans in the industry. If you are too unprofessional to read and follow simple submission instructions, or for some reason can’t read, they don’t want anything to do with you. Remember, these are professionals. They’ve been at this a long time, and they can smell an unpromising, slow-learning amateur from a continent away.

After reading your query and sample, if they still like what they are reading, they will likely ask to read the whole manuscript. Then, and only then, (and after an agonizing long wait, most cases – I’m talking months – really) will you find out if you have landed a publisher willing to publish your work. So, first off, you need to learn how to write an effective, attention-getting, professional looking query letter. There are plenty of sources for tutorials on the do’s and don’ts of writing a good query letter. Do a Google search. Two sources I highly recommend from personal experience are Carolyn Howard Johnson’s book, The Frugal Book Promoter, and Janet Elaine Smith’s Promo Paks.

Now we come to the fourth viable option, landing a contract with a small traditional publishing house. Here are some of the advantages of going that route:

A) They pay all the expenses to publish your book. You have no out of pocket costs. Unless, that is, they don’t have an in-house editor to your liking and/or standards and you need to hire one. And, a side note here, you must use a good editor. The best authors with dozens of best-sellers already to their credit have an editor. Even editors use another editor for their own books. As the author, you often cannot “see” what is actually on the page. You think it’s there, but it’s not clear or missing altogether – or visa versa. Good editors will spot plot/subplot/timeline inconsistencies, character trait/speech inconsistencies, poor sentence and paragraph structure; I could go on and on. This is mandatory – hire the services of a professional editor, a good one. Back to the advantages.

B) Unlike the Big Houses, small traditional publishers still allow you a large amount of control over your work. You will still most likely have the say in what the cover looks like. A company I worked with recently, (Cambridge Books), even welcomes the author submitting the cover art his or herself if they have it. Also, if they like your manuscript enough to pay to publish it, they probably won’t demand that you rework it in any major way.

Now some disadvantages to consider.

A) As with POD’s, small traditional publishing houses do not have staff and budgets to market your book for you. You are just as alone here as with the POD’s. Sorry, but that’s just the way it is.

B) When I say “small” traditional publisher, that’s exactly what I mean. You have not hit the big time. Getting your first “real” contract can lull you into a deadly slumber, thinking you’ve “made it” and have no work to do except write for a living from now on. Your book could go nowhere, and probably will, unless you start promoting and marketing the living bejeebers out of it starting months before the expected release date.

C) You make less money on the sale per book. Since the publisher has shelled out the bucks to publish your book, they take a higher cut of the proceeds from sales. Your royalties will be a smaller percentage than with POD’s, and your net ROI will be somewhat less on personal sales than with a POD publisher.

There you have it. Four avenues to consider for publishing your book. My best wishes I send to you as your pursue your new career in the wonderful and challenging world of literature.

Marvin D Wilson
Blog at: http://theoldsilly.com
Avatar
Award Winning Author of Owen Fiddler
Tweet me at: http://twitter.com/Paize_Fiddler

Elizabeth Spann Craig

View posts by Elizabeth Spann Craig
Elizabeth writes the Memphis Barbeque series (as Riley Adams) and the Southern Quilting mysteries for Penguin and writes the Myrtle Clover series for Midnight Ink and independently. She also has a blog, which was named by Writer’s Digest as one of the 101 Best Websites for Writers. There she posts on the writing craft, finding inspiration in everyday life, and fitting writing into a busy schedule.

20 Comments

  1. Margot KinbergOctober 26, 2009

    Wow! This is really useful information! You’ve outlined everything so clearly. Thanks for the very helpful post.

  2. M.J. NichollsOctober 26, 2009

    Re: Stephen King’s “On Writing.”

    There seems to be a consensus that this text is “essential” reading for aspiring authors. I would disagree.

    It’s certainly a helpful text for aspiring WRITERS, not folks trying to get their first book published.

    I think it’s important to differentiate this, since the professional first-timer should be proofing their work with grammar/style aids (i.e. Chicago Manual of Style) and workshopping their writing among friends/professionals.

    For an emerging writer, King’s text is the perfect list of DOs and DON’Ts. But it’s certainly a starting-out text.

    Anyway. Great post. Largely agreed.

  3. Journaling WomanOctober 26, 2009

    I miss Elizabeth, BUT Wow, what great information.

    I have only had a few published stories in small magazines and years ago, so I am soaking in everything you all say.

    The self-publishing route is a lot of work. My dad self publishes and always sells out locally.

    I will reread this to make sure I get it all.

    thanks-Teresa

  4. Crystal Clear ProofingOctober 26, 2009

    Very interesting post, Mr. Guest Host Marvin! I feel like a broken record, but I continue to learn so much about the other side of this business. Quite enlightening and helpful information!

  5. Julie DaoOctober 26, 2009

    This was some really excellent information and clarified many of the points of the business for me. Thanks so much!

  6. Karen WalkerOctober 26, 2009

    Excellent advice, Marvin. Again,wish I’d known you folks BEFORE I went through all the agony of getting my book published.
    Elizabeth, hope your son is feeling better and that you remain healthy.
    Karen

  7. The Old SillyOctober 26, 2009

    First off, thanks to Elizabeth for having me on today!

    Margot – thank you, I try and help when I can.

    M.J., you know you bring up a valid point, perhaps I should revise the advice in it’s wording re: On Writing a bit. Thanks for the feedback and overall endorsement, though.

    Crystal, thanks – this industry does indeed have MANY facets to it, doesn’t it?

    Marvin D Wilson

  8. Jane Kennedy SuttonOctober 26, 2009

    Good article, Marvin.

    “Your book could go nowhere, and probably will, unless you start promoting and marketing the living bejeebers out of it starting months before the expected release date.”

    In this day in age I think this advice applies to any publication route taken – not just to the small publishing houses.

  9. Elspeth AntonelliOctober 26, 2009

    Nicely done post, sir. Clear, informative and logical. I’m sure many people will be thanking you for showing them the many roads they can take.

    Elspeth

  10. Jen ChandlerOctober 26, 2009

    Thank you for this breakdown, Marvin. It’s very useful and realistic. And it’s not nearly as depressing as most of what I’m reading these days about getting published. A lot of hard work is ahead of me!!

    Jen

  11. Helen GingerOctober 26, 2009

    Great post Marvin. Very helpful information and you’ve not varnished over the downside. This is a heads-up for anyone hoping to get published.

    Helen
    Straight From Hel

  12. L. Diane WolfeOctober 26, 2009

    You nailed it, Marvin! I teach seminars on publishing and I’m always hearing these forms of publishing misquoted or represented (sometimes by those claiming to be experts) so it is very refreshing to hear you know your stuff.

    And unless you ARE Stephen King, you’ll have to do a lot of the marketing no matter what!

  13. The Old SillyOctober 26, 2009

    Journaling Woman – hats off to your dad! That’s a lot of work and I’m glad for him he can make it work so well.

    Jane – got that right!

    Helen, Appreciate it, especially from someone who knows the industry as well as YOU do.

    Julie – thanks, glad to know the post clarifies things well.

    Karen – TELL me about it! I wish I had read this myself when trying to get my first book pub’d.

    Diane – yeah – I’ve actually considered having my name changed to King. (wink)

    Elspeth, thank you, yeah – the Old Silly can do informative and logical – lol

    Marvin D Wilson

  14. kerrycharactersOctober 26, 2009

    Thank you for this – you’ve just leap-frogged me over the researching your four options. Your blog has been bookmarked and I intend to make as much use of your learning curve as possible. Thanks for your generosity in sharing the grizzly details.

  15. Dorte HOctober 26, 2009

    Nice to meet you again here, Marvin.

    Very useful post, perhaps especially this observation: “… you must be realistic in your expectations”

    I think I am (at least I have become fairly philosophical about receiving rejections), but I often run into authors-in-spe who seem to believe fame is round the next corner just because they have finished the first draft of their first manuscript.

  16. Jemi FraserOctober 26, 2009

    What an informative post!! Thanks so much for compiling all of this info for us newbies, Marvin! It is much appreciated :)

  17. Galen Kindley--AuthorOctober 26, 2009

    Hey, Marv, good to see you here, after all the hosting you do for others it’s nice to see Elizabeth host you…kudos to you both.

    Thanks for the well written, no-nonsense summary. Wish I’d had this explain ten years ago. Saved me some heart ache for sure..

    Best Regards, Galen

    Imagineering Fiction Blog

  18. Elizabeth Spann CraigOctober 26, 2009

    Thanks so much, Marvin, for posting for me today! I really do appreciate it.

    My son is still feverish, lethargic, and has a nasty cough. But he’s not as bad as some of the horrible cases we’ve heard about with H1N1 lately. Knock on wood! And so far we’ve been very fortunate that nothing has spread.

    Thanks so much for the really informative post, Marvin. And for all the well-wishes!

  19. N A SharpeOctober 27, 2009

    Hi Marvin and Elizabeth! Great post Marvin with wonderful insights and food for thought for routes to pursue. Also, something to keep in mind, if you are going the self publishing, vanity or POD route is to shop around and find out exactly what you are getting for your investment.

    Nancy, from Realms of Thought…

  20. Creative ChroniclerOctober 30, 2009

    Thanks for the great info Marvin!

Comments are closed.

Scroll to top